1. What is this strength?
Judgment, sometimes called open-mindedness, is one of the 24 VIA Character Strengths recognized in positive psychology. This strength reflects our capacity to carefully evaluate information, question assumptions, and make well-balanced decisions based on evidence rather than bias or impulse. In the VIA model, Judgment is grouped within the Wisdom and Knowledge family, qualities that help us navigate complexity with discernment.
Researchers commonly assess Judgment through the VIA-Inventory of Strengths (VIA-IS) questionnaire, which includes sample items like:
- “I weigh evidence fairly before making decisions.”
- “I like to look at all sides of an issue.”
At its core, Judgment is about seeing more than one side, pausing before concluding, welcoming diverse perspectives, and being willing to revise thinking. Peterson & Seligman (2004) found that individuals high in Judgment report greater decision satisfaction and fewer regrets, contributing meaningfully to overall life satisfaction.
2. Behavior & Examples
High expression:- Taking time to consider facts and viewpoints before acting
- Remaining flexible in the face of new information
- Being less swayed by first impressions or social pressures
- Making snap judgments or clinging to initial beliefs
- Dismissing opinions that contradict one’s own
- Struggling to adapt when new evidence emerges
-
Scientist weighing evidence:
Before accepting a hypothesis, a scientist seeks multiple data points and invites critique.
Coaching takeaway: Lean into curiosity before reaching conclusions. -
Mediator facilitating dialogue:
A skilled mediator listens to all sides, balancing empathy with critical questioning to guide fair outcomes.
Takeaway: Balance empathy with critical reasoning. -
Everyday conflict resolution:
In a personal disagreement, pausing to re-examine assumptions enables resolution without escalation.
Takeaway: Pause and check assumptions in tense moments.
3. Strengths & Pitfalls
Benefits:- Encourages sound decisions and reduces impulsivity (Stanovich & West, 2008)
- Linked to openness and adaptive problem-solving (Kaufman et al., 2016)
- Supports healthy skepticism, vital in relationships and teamwork
- Fosters resilience by enabling flexible coping during setbacks
- Overthinking can lead to “paralysis by analysis” and delay action
- Persistent doubt may undermine self-confidence or trust in others
- Can turn critical, dismissing new ideas out of excessive scrutiny
4. Cross-Domain Parallels
- Big Five: Closely mirrors Openness to Experience, valuing novelty, variety, and intellectual curiosity.
- MBTI: Resonates with the Intuition (N) dimension; favoring abstraction, patterns, and integrative thinking.
- Ayurveda: Aligns with the balanced Vata dosha, flexible and agile mentally, but vulnerable to indecision under stress.
- Zodiac: Reflects the Libra archetype: fairness, weighing options, seeking equilibrium.
- Hero Archetype / Shadow: The Wise Sage, clear, discerning guidance; The Perpetual Doubter, stuck in endless what-ifs.
Integration Map: Picture Judgment as a central node connecting psychological, philosophical, and archetypal traditions, a true multidimensional indicator of open-mindedness.
5. This Strength in Lifemap’s Life Categories
- Career: Guides strategic choices and career pivots.
Prompt: When did pausing to reconsider help your career path? - Relationships: Allows for full, empathic listening.
Prompt: How do you suspend judgment to hear someone fully? - Family: Supports healthy discussion across generations.
Prompt: What family story changed when viewed from another angle? - Emotional: Helps rein in reactivity.
Prompt: How do you question initial feelings before acting? - Spiritual: Makes space for pluralism and doubt.
Prompt: Can you hold questions as sacred as answers? - Health & Fitness: Favors evidence over quick fixes.
Prompt: What new evidence changed your health habits? - Lifestyle: Boosts adaptability to changing routines.
Prompt: When did trying something new benefit your routine? - Financial: Protects against impulsive decisions.
Prompt: What’s your process for big financial decisions? - Community: Enables open dialogue despite differences.
Prompt: Where can curiosity replace quick judgments? - Creativity: Sparks breakthroughs by integrating new ideas.
Prompt: What’s an idea you initially resisted that proved useful? - Learning: Hones critical thinking and discernment.
Prompt: How do you test new theories for yourself? - Life Vision: Updates long-term plans with fresh insight.
Prompt: How often do you revise your ‘why’?
6. The Lifemap Holistic Coaching Perspective
Judgment, however powerful, is never the whole self-portrait. Isolated, it risks becoming detached, even cold, just as too little can leave us reactive or closed. Lifemap weaves Judgment with strengths like Courage, Humanity, and Wisdom, inviting you into ongoing self-discovery rather than fixed identity. Through a guided profile that places you at the center of your own legend, you’re not just uncovering traits, but building inner architecture, blending modern research with reflective coaching prompts and ancient wisdom.
Integration Map: Imagine Judgment as one hue on a color wheel of strengths, shaded and deepened by philosophical insight, reflective practice, and everyday action.
7. Conclusion & Coaching CTA
Deepening your awareness of Judgment expands your capacity for lifelong learning and wiser living. Grossmann et al. (2020) showed that open-minded reasoning is linked to psychological well-being and more adaptive life outcomes. Remember, Judgment isn’t a label, it’s a living practice of curiosity and recalibration. Ready to take insight into daily life? Join Lifemap’s 7-day Hero’s Journey course, a guided exploration that helps you meet the open-minded hero inside you.
– Valentin
